Editor's News Trails
Publisher-associated editorial trails will appear here when an editorial publishing workflow is available.
Publisher profile
johnbjudis.substack.com
Explore recent coverage from this publisher, with reporting context brought together on Scroll News.
Reporting, in context
This is from “Swamp Notes” on the Financial Times’ web page. To see this costs over $900 a year, which is beyond my own budget, so I thought I would copy it here for my substack readers. Rana Foroohar leads off and I follow. By Rana Foroohar: A recent piece in the Wall Street Journal announced that “a new political era appears to be taking hold from Paris, Texas to Paris, France. Voters are becoming less attached to the parties their parents voted for and more likely to try out new parties or new pitches, on the left and the right”. This put me in mind of a piece my colleague Gillian Tett wrote years ago about the “pick ‘n’ mix” generation of young people who take a bit of this and a bit of that from whatever political or cultural ideas they most like and blend it into a highly personalised ideological mix. Perhaps this accounts, at least in part, for the way in which voters in the midterm elections could express both concern about open borders and disdain for Donald Trump’s aggressive deportations and ICE tactics. Or the “horseshoe” phenomenon in which some Maga labour voters who had been labour-left Democrats pre-2016 swung back to their progressive roots once again. Whatever the reasons, politics have become more extreme. This raises the question of whether the blue wave we’ve just seen will be lasting or — just like the Maga phenomenon itself — something that will flip more quickly. My partner in the Swamp today is John Judis, an astute political analyst and commentator who recently wrote a piece for Compact looking at just this phenomenon. As he points out, ever since Democrats lost their traditional white working-class majority after 1968, there hasn’t really been a dominant party in this country. Since the 2014 election, power has changed in one of the two houses of Congress or the White House every biennial election. This is something that is mirrored in many parts of Europe now as well. Voters in France, Italy, Germany and the UK seem to swing as radically as — if not more so — than those in the US. And younger people are much more likely than older ones to identify as independent, which makes them more likely to shift with the political winds. What is this all about? I sometimes wonder if the high-speed media cycle has something to do with it. A public inundated with information expects political change and policy accomplishments on the same timeline as that on which they consume their digital media. It is always amazing to me how much credit and blame politicians get for things (debt, inflation, growth) that are the result of a multitude of factors that came well before they were in office and will continue regardless of what decisions they make. Perhaps this is simply the nature of democracy. But it leads to many unrealistic expectations about politics and the world. In any case, I’m interested in whether some of the big whiplash trends we saw in this election cycle will stick. It seems to me, for example, that the American South is likely to stay blue — or at least purple — for some time, given that the shift towards Democrats there is as much about growth as it is about dissatisfaction with Trump’s economic mismanagement. Younger, richer people tend to be more liberal — and the South is where they are moving and where trend growth is higher. On the other hand, I wonder if the Midwest could flip red again if Democrats aren’t able to convince working people they can do a better job than Republicans, particularly if you see a conservative candidate in 2028 who understands the economic reasons for populism. While I think that some union voters turned away from Trump because they felt betrayed, I believe most working people in the heartland are thinking about the kitchen table and the medicine cabinet and who can best help them pay for what’s on it or in it. Given that inflation tends to be sticky, it will be a tough task to bring down prices in a way that allows Democrats to take credit by 2028. I’m also curious about whether Europe or the US will be more politically volatile in the coming years. If measured by percentage point swings away from traditional parties, Europe wins on volatility over the last 15 years or so. Will that hold true in the future? John, you ponder these and many other pressing political questions in your Substack. What is your take on what the midterms and shifting voting patterns tell us about political volatility in the US? And what should we take from the recent populist swings in Europe? Where will things calm down first? Or won’t they? Recommended reading I’ve just finished Sherry Turkle’s book Artificial Intimacy: Who We Become When We Talk to Machines, which is well worth a read. This is the woman who first thought about how personal computers would change how we think; her warning about empathy becoming a pose in the age of artificial intelligence is cautionary. I did a Lunch with the FT years ago with her and it’s still one of my favourites. I couldn’t help but think about James Fallows’ extremely prescient New York Times magazine piece that came out on Thursday, about how the Trump administration has made air travel less safe, as I was sitting for hours the very next day on the Newark tarmac following the nationwide FAA ground stop. In the FT, I enjoyed Rob Armstrong’s dissection of midterms sartorial messaging, as well as Martin Sandbu’s conversation with economist Isabella Weber, whose new book Anti-Fascist Economics is worth a read as well. John Judis replies There were two things that contributed to the unexpected success of the Democrats in the midterm elections. The first was that longstanding trends towards the party, which can ebb and flow, cascaded in this election. Democrats have been acquiring centre-left majorities in urban-suburban metropolitan areas. That helps explain their victories in erstwhile red states like Texas, Georgia, North Carolina and even Kansas. Kansas is known as a farm state, but in the 2026 Senate vote 68 per cent of the electorate came from the Kansas City, Topeka and Wichita areas. Texas is 73 per cent urban and suburban. The Dallas-Fort Worth and Houston areas alone comprised 44 per cent of the electorate. Democrats have always been strong among urban voters, but in 2026 the party improved its percentage of the vote among suburban voters. These trends have not guaranteed Democratic victories because they have been countered by a shift to the Republican Party in small towns and rural areas. But in 2026, the urban and suburban voters predominated and many of the white rural and small-town Trump voters stayed home. The second factor was Republican complicity in Trump’s horrific presidency. The Iran war, the inflation caused by it, the arbitrary tariffs, the alleged corruption, ICE and deportations, racial redistricting, you name it. Trump and the Republicans’ conduct removed and reversed the large gains the party had made among Hispanic and Black voters. In House races in 2024, Republicans won the Latino male vote by 53 per cent to 45 per cent. In 2026, Democrats won them by 64 per cent to 35 per cent. Republicans won almost a quarter of votes among Black men in 2024 House elections; Democrats won Black men by 89 to 11 per cent in 2026. Combine that with increased Black and Hispanic turnout, including in rural areas, and you have Democratic victories in Mississippi, Texas and the Carolinas. Trump’s war in Iran and the rise in gasoline and diesel prices undermined Republican support in heavily-oil dependent states like Montana and Iowa. It wasn’t just the price of diesel for tractors or gasoline for pick-up trucks, it was also the cost of fertiliser. If not for the skyrocketing price of heating oil, Troy Jackson may not have unseated Susan Collins in Maine. If Trump had governed like he did during his first term — without “liberation day” tariffs or Middle Eastern wars — Democrats would probably have still gained House and Senate seats, but not to the degree they did. If Trump continues along the same course in his last two years, Democrats are very likely to solidify their majority in Congress and win the White House. Beyond that, as Trump leaves the stage, it is very possible that the parties will revert to the teeter-totter alternation in power that has characterised party politics for almost five decades. The parties are still demographically at about equal strength. Republicans should get back their edge in states whose economies are based on resource extraction. A state like Kansas is unlikely to turn blue. Each party will continue to have extreme wings — Republicans have Maga and the Democrats have police abolitionists and open borders advocates — that can potentially doom their chances at the polls. Voters will resent Republican tax breaks for the rich; they are also leery of Democrats’ social spending. But the havoc Trump has wrought may provide the Democrats an opportunity to create an advantage beyond 2028. From 1932 to 1980, Democrats benefited from being seen as the party of the common man (and woman) and Republicans as the party of the rich. Ronald Reagan and Trump challenged that perception. They conveyed an impression of the Republicans as the party of the average American and the Democrats as the party of the woke coastal elites. In his second term, Trump — with his Mar-a-Lago cronies and Silicon Valley ultra-wealthy — may have revived the older, and politically deadly, impression of the Republicans as the party of the callous rich. Democratic candidates, from Abdul El-Sayed on the left to Adam Hamilton in the centre, ran successfully against the GOP as the party of the “billionaire class”. In his second term, Trump may have also undone the Republican Party’s attempt to win its share of the Hispanic, Black male and young male vote. The Hispanic vote is particularly important to Republican efforts to win majorities nationally and in states like Texas. In California, Republican failure to win back Hispanic votes after a Republican-backed xenophobic initiative in 1994 doomed the party to permanent minority status. Could the same thing now happen outside California? Young voters have been trending strongly Democratic since the early 2000s, but Trump enjoyed particular success among young men, winning their vote by as much as 14 percentage points in 2024. In this month’s midterms, Democrats won 59 per cent of this demographic. Has Trump allowed Democrats to regain their hold over these voters? This is, admittedly, windy speculation. Great events — wars and the bursting of mega-investment bubbles (what could I be thinking of?) — can push politics off course. And in American politics, so much depends upon who holds the presidency and what he or she does with it. That’s the lesson of Trump’s second term and the reason why Democrats can look to the future with a more hopeful gaze than Republicans.
Follow a story across time
Explore editorial and community perspectives on connected reporting.
Distinct perspectives · No trails available yet
Publisher-associated editorial trails will appear here when an editorial publishing workflow is available.
Public reader-created trails featuring this publisher's coverage are not shown until privacy-safe discovery is available.
Explore the reporting
Browse recurring subjects across this publisher's coverage.
Publisher-specific topics
Topic discovery is not available for this publisher yet.