SCROLL NEWS / DISCOVERY

Search headlines

Find the stories shaping the conversation.

Search mode
Refine results
Active filters Keyword All time

Results for " stephanie wescott " 1 found 🔀 AI-powered Shuffle

The politics of making men the victims of misogyny

Hello! Instead of Hannah’s regular Monday column this evening, we have something a bit different for you all from Dr Stephanie Wescott - a brilliant feminist lecturer and researcher from Monash University. For our paid subs, Hannah’s usual column will be coming to you later this week, after she’s moved through the craziness of her first major campaign fundraiser tomorrow - check her Instagram for details! 98% of the work Cheek Media publishes is entirely free for our audience to engage with. We rely on our amazing subscriber base to support us in continuing to cover the stories and explore the angles that the mainstream media won’t. We’re trying to reach 3000 new subscribers by Christmas, we’d love you to purchase an annual subscription today to support independent media. Subscribe Boys deserve care, connection and freedom from the expectations of masculinity. But none of this requires us to pretend that patriarchy distributes power, vulnerability or violence equally, writes Dr Stephanie Wescott. It is a mostly agreed fact that women bear the brunt of men’s violence. Although we tend to use terms like gendered violence or domestic and family violence -language that can obscure the genders of both victims and perpetrators - feminist reporting and activism leave little room for confusion about whose lives are being taken, and by whom. What has begun to creep into public discourse, though, is a concerning debate about the social conditions that enable this violence, who can claim to be harmed by them and who is deserving of sympathy. Increasingly, we are being asked to consider boys as central victims of the manosphere and, more indeed, of misogyny itself. Last month, the ABC released its own contribution to the ongoing cultural examination of the ‘manosphere’ phenomenon: a 3-episode documentary on the ABC, State of Man, hosted by Marc Funnell. Synopsised as an examination of ‘the heart of masculinity in Australia’, sadly, it neglects to explore with the same empathy and investment that the manosphere, while ‘shaping’ men, by virtue also shapes what they expect from women and how they treat them. These harms are now abundantly clear. We are seeing it in schools, where women are considering leaving teaching because the sexism and misogyny is so rife; among men who have used violence against their partners; and among teenage boys in Australia, who are the most likely age group to express gendered hostility and support for rigid gender roles. A recently released recording of a panel chaired by Julia Gillard is described as exploring how misogyny constrains ‘both men and women’. We must be clear that while this is true, it is not unanimous for all men and all women. It is important that we recognise that a boy’s restricted emotional expression and a woman’s exposure to his misogynistic abuse may emerge from the same gender order, but they are not interchangeable experiences that should be spoken in the same sentence as if they are equivalent. What is clear, though, is that misogyny becomes a more palatable concern when men are explicitly named among its victims. This change in discourse warrants scrutiny, for its political inclinations and for its implications. Without naming it and examining what it does, we risk minimising the extent to which misogyny constrains women’s movement through the world, our sense of safety in our bodies and homes, the decisions available to us, and the limits imposed on our lives. We risk allowing a conversation about the conditions that sustain men’s violence to become, once again, a conversation that makes the unique suffering experienced by women so blurred that it becomes indistinguishable. Feminists have long understood that patriarchy harms people of all genders. We know that rigid expectations of masculinity constrain boys’ emotional lives, relationships and possibilities. Boys deserve care, connection and freedom from those expectations. None of this requires us to pretend that patriarchy distributes power, vulnerability or violence equally. Further, when we insist on centring the harms experienced by men, we preclude recognition of intersecting harms that are intensified by race, class, disability, sexuality and transphobia, which create vulnerability in distinct and often catastrophic ways. The state of this discourse is particularly dangerous given there is already a sympathetic audience for the suggestion that gender equality is a discriminatory pursuit. A 2023 survey by King’s College found that 51 per cent of Australian men agreed that equal rights for women had gone far enough. Men were also substantially more likely to believe they were being asked to do too much to support equality. Similarly, the 2021 National Community Attitudes towards Violence Against Women (NCAS) data found that attitudes towards gender equality had a stronger association with violence-supportive attitudes, and that men were more likely to believe that gendered violence is not an issue in their suburb or town. What does it mean when our public conversation insists on equalising the harms women and men experience under patriarchy? Whose interests are served by a politics where it seems compulsory for us to declare our sympathy for men alongside our grief for women whose safety, freedom and lives are threatened by men’s violence? This insistence on equivalence has consequences. It risks reinforcing the belief that women’s claims to injustice are overstated, that gender equality has gone too far, and that men are being unfairly asked to relinquish power. These beliefs are connected to violence-supportive attitudes. They cause harm. A conversation about misogyny must be able to stay with those it targets and whose lives are threatened by its existence. If every account of women’s oppression must return to what men are going through, we need to ask whose discomfort we are protecting, and whose suffering we have learned to look past. About the author Dr Stephanie Wescott is an academic at Monash University where her work focuses on gender, schooling and violence prevention. Her research examines the influence of misogynistic and manosphere ideologies in education settings, school-based gendered violence, and the institutional conditions that shape how gendered harms are recognised, responded to and prevented in schools. Thanks for reading Cheek Media Co. ! This post is public so feel free to share it. Share

cheekmedia.substack.com logo
Nov 16 • 1:39 AM EST • Politics • cheekmedia.substack.com
😐 Neutral (11%)
ahah
52%
love
24%
wow
24%